You found the deal. You analyzed the CIM. The EBITDA looks real, the seller seems motivated, and the ask price is in range. You draft your letter of intent, send it over, and… nothing. Two weeks later, the broker tells you they went with another buyer.

For first-time acquirers, the LOI is where more deals die than anywhere else. Not because the economics were wrong, but because the letter itself sent the wrong signal. Sellers and brokers are reading between the lines of every LOI they receive, and if yours looks like it came from someone who's never closed a deal, it goes to the bottom of the stack.

Here are the five mistakes we see most often.

1. Leading with a lowball offer and a plan to "negotiate up"

The anchoring strategy that works in real estate doesn't work in M&A. When a broker receives 12 LOIs on a decent business, they're triaging. Your 3.2x offer on a business listed at 4.0x isn't going to start a conversation — it's going to get filed.

This doesn't mean you have to pay asking price. But your offer needs to be in the range where a seller sees you as serious. If the business is listed at 4.0x SDE and you think it's worth 3.5x, put in at 3.5x and explain why in clear terms: customer concentration, capex needs, working capital assumptions. A well-reasoned offer at 3.5x beats a lazy one at 4.0x.

A seller who's been through three failed deals doesn't want the highest bidder. They want the one who's going to close.

2. Being vague about financing

Nothing spooks a seller faster than uncertainty about whether you can actually pay for their business. "Financing to be determined" or "exploring multiple capital sources" translates to: this person doesn't have the money yet.

Spell it out. If you're going SBA 7(a), say so. If you have an equity commitment from a search fund, name the fund and the amount. If you're bringing seller financing into the structure, lay out the terms you're proposing — don't leave it for "later discussion." The more specific your financing section, the more credible your LOI.

3. Requesting a 120-day exclusivity period

You want time to do thorough diligence. Understandable. But asking for four months of exclusivity on your first LOI tells the seller you either don't know what you're doing or you're planning to renegotiate after they've taken the business off the market.

Sixty days is standard. Seventy-five is fine for complex deals. Anything beyond 90 needs a strong justification (multi-location, regulatory approvals, environmental phase II). If you genuinely need 120 days, explain exactly why — with a diligence timeline attached — and offer a breakup fee to show you're serious.

4. Skipping the "why me" section

Brokers tell us this is the most underrated part of an LOI. Sellers aren't just selling a revenue stream — many of them built this business over 20 years. They want to know their employees will be treated well and the business won't be gutted for parts.

One paragraph is enough. Talk about your operating plan, not your financial model. "I plan to retain the existing management team and invest in the service department" lands better than "I see significant margin expansion opportunities through headcount optimization."

If you have relevant industry experience, this is where it goes. If you're a first-time buyer, lean into your commitment to the business and the community. Sellers pick the buyer they trust, not just the one who pays the most.

5. Over-lawyering the first draft

Your LOI is non-binding (except exclusivity, confidentiality, and a few other provisions). It doesn't need to read like a purchase agreement. When a seller opens a 14-page LOI with representations, warranties, and indemnification language, their first call is to their attorney — and their attorney's first instinct is to push back on everything.

Keep it to 3–5 pages. Cover the essentials: purchase price, structure, financing, timeline, key assumptions, and exclusivity. Save the legal detail for the definitive agreement where it belongs. A clean, readable LOI that hits the key points signals competence. A bloated one signals that you're going to be difficult to work with.

Write better LOIs, faster

DealSpark's AI LOI generator builds structured, broker-ready letters of intent from your deal data. Customize terms, financing structure, and closing timeline in minutes.

Try DealSpark Free

The LOI is a trust signal

Every element of your LOI — the price, the terms, the language, the length — is telling the seller and their broker something about who you are as a buyer. The best LOIs we've seen aren't the ones with the highest price. They're the ones that make the seller think: this person is going to close.

Get the economics right, be specific about financing, keep your ask reasonable, show that you care about the business, and don't over-complicate it. That's the formula. It's not flashy, but it works.